Eighth Appellate District Court Opinion Summaries

07/03/2008

Case Name Case No. Topics and Issues Author Decided

State v. Ashford 90276 Sexual predator classification; agreed remand. Sweeney 7/3/2008

State v. Ballard 90248 Ineffective assistance of counsel; resentence; R.C. 2929.14(E)(1); State v. Foster. Celebrezze 7/3/2008

State v. Crosswhite 89104 Double jeopardy; Fifth Amendment; Fourteenth Amendment; felony; misdemeanor; Criminal Rule 11; Sixth Amendment; ineffective assistance of counsel Calabrese 7/3/2008

Louden, v. A.W. Chesterton Co. 90183 EMPLOYER INTENTIONAL TORT; SUMMARY JUDGMENT; DE NOVO STANDARD OF REVIEW; 3 PART EMPLOYER INTENTIONAL TORT TEST; ASBESTOS; SUBSTANTIAL CERTAINTY OF HARM. Cooney 7/3/2008

Cynergies Consulting, Inc. v. Wheeler 90225 Civ.R. 12(B)(6), motion to dismiss, de novo, non-competition agreement, remedies, trade secrets, R.C. 1331.61, temporal limitations, geographic limitations, time bar, injunction, damages, declaratory judgment, accounting. Kilbane 7/3/2008

State v. Green 90092 Exculpatory evidence. Dyke 7/3/2008

State v. Futo 89791 vouching; credibility; Boston; maximum, consecutive sentences; sufficiency; manifest weight Gallagher 7/3/2008

State v. Lundy 90229 R.C. 2921.38; harassment by an inmate; spitting; sufficiency; manifest weight. Gallagher 7/3/2008

State v. Clark 90148 Rape; victim sleeping; R.C. 2907.02(A)(1)(c); force Blackmon 7/3/2008

State Farm Fire & Cas. Co. v. Harpster 90012 CIV.R. 56/SUMMARY JUDGMENT; COLLATERAL ESTOPPEL; R.C. 2903.12(A)(1)AGGRAVATED ASSAULT; INSURANCE POLICY/OCCURRENCE OR ACCIDENT; BODILY INJURY/EXPECTED OR INTENDED; CRIMINAL CONVICTION/INTENTIONAL ACTS EXCLUSION. Boyle 7/3/2008

State v. Wilson 90267 Assault; Evidence, sufficiency, weight, Possession of Criminal Tools; Sentence, agreement, minimum Rocco 7/3/2008

Crosby v. McFaul 91641 Habeas corpus; excessive bail; abuse of discretion; and $25,000 bail for robbery. Cooney 7/2/2008

Plymouth Park Tax Servs. v. Frazier 90343, 90352, 90353, 90354, 90356, 90357, 90464, 90525, and 90526 Final appealable order; magistrate’s decision; attorney fees. Blackmon 7/1/2008

Glass v. Terry 91704 Procedendo, discretion of court, adequate remedy at law, Civil Rule 10(A). Calabrese 7/1/2008

State v. Hooks 88713 Reopening; prosecutorial misconduct; manifest weight; lesser included offense; involuntary manslaughter; instruction; interrogatory. Calabrese 7/1/2008

State v. Halder 87974 Res judicata; ineffective assistance of appellate counsel; ineffective assistance of trial counsel. prejudice. McMonagle 7/1/2008

State ex rel. Frazier v. Saffold 91188 Procedendo and moot. Stewart 6/30/2008

State ex rel. Skaggs v. Gallagher 91385 Mandamus; motions; moot; Civ.R. 10(A); address. Gallagher 6/27/2008

Case Name	Case No.	Topics and Issues	Author	Decided
State v. Ashford	90276	Sexual predator classification; agreed remand.	Sweeney	7/3/2008
State v. Ballard	90248	Ineffective assistance of counsel; resentence; R.C. 2929.14(E)(1); State v. Foster.	Celebrezze	7/3/2008
State v. Crosswhite	89104	Double jeopardy; Fifth Amendment; Fourteenth Amendment; felony; misdemeanor; Criminal Rule 11; Sixth Amendment; ineffective assistance of counsel	Calabrese	7/3/2008
Louden, v. A.W. Chesterton Co.	90183	EMPLOYER INTENTIONAL TORT; SUMMARY JUDGMENT; DE NOVO STANDARD OF REVIEW; 3 PART EMPLOYER INTENTIONAL TORT TEST; ASBESTOS; SUBSTANTIAL CERTAINTY OF HARM.	Cooney	7/3/2008
Cynergies Consulting, Inc. v. Wheeler	90225	Civ.R. 12(B)(6), motion to dismiss, de novo, non-competition agreement, remedies, trade secrets, R.C. 1331.61, temporal limitations, geographic limitations, time bar, injunction, damages, declaratory judgment, accounting.	Kilbane	7/3/2008
State v. Green	90092	Exculpatory evidence.	Dyke	7/3/2008
State v. Futo	89791	vouching; credibility; Boston; maximum, consecutive sentences; sufficiency; manifest weight	Gallagher	7/3/2008
State v. Lundy	90229	R.C. 2921.38; harassment by an inmate; spitting; sufficiency; manifest weight.	Gallagher	7/3/2008
State v. Clark	90148	Rape; victim sleeping; R.C. 2907.02(A)(1)(c); force	Blackmon	7/3/2008
State Farm Fire & Cas. Co. v. Harpster	90012	CIV.R. 56/SUMMARY JUDGMENT; COLLATERAL ESTOPPEL; R.C. 2903.12(A)(1)AGGRAVATED ASSAULT; INSURANCE POLICY/OCCURRENCE OR ACCIDENT; BODILY INJURY/EXPECTED OR INTENDED; CRIMINAL CONVICTION/INTENTIONAL ACTS EXCLUSION.	Boyle	7/3/2008
State v. Wilson	90267	Assault; Evidence, sufficiency, weight, Possession of Criminal Tools; Sentence, agreement, minimum	Rocco	7/3/2008
Crosby v. McFaul	91641	Habeas corpus; excessive bail; abuse of discretion; and $25,000 bail for robbery.	Cooney	7/2/2008
Plymouth Park Tax Servs. v. Frazier	90343, 90352, 90353, 90354, 90356, 90357, 90464, 90525, and 90526	Final appealable order; magistrate’s decision; attorney fees.	Blackmon	7/1/2008
Glass v. Terry	91704	Procedendo, discretion of court, adequate remedy at law, Civil Rule 10(A).	Calabrese	7/1/2008
State v. Hooks	88713	Reopening; prosecutorial misconduct; manifest weight; lesser included offense; involuntary manslaughter; instruction; interrogatory.	Calabrese	7/1/2008
State v. Halder	87974	Res judicata; ineffective assistance of appellate counsel; ineffective assistance of trial counsel. prejudice.	McMonagle	7/1/2008
State ex rel. Frazier v. Saffold	91188	Procedendo and moot.	Stewart	6/30/2008
State ex rel. Skaggs v. Gallagher	91385	Mandamus; motions; moot; Civ.R. 10(A); address.	Gallagher	6/27/2008